featured photo
The Kitchen
Brought to you by
Body Wrappers;
New York Flash Review Sponsor
the New York manufacturer of fine dance apparel for women and girls. Click here to see a sample of our products and a list of web sites for purchasing.
With Body Wrappers it's always
performance at its best.

Go back to Flash Reviews
Go Home

Flash Review 3, 5-1: Stereotypes of Stereotypes
The Gaps in Alpert's "Images of Women"

By Vanessa Manko
Copyright 2002 Vanessa Manko

NEW YORK -- Mrs. Cleaver, Barbie, Wonder Woman, Rosy the Riveter, Charlie's Angels, and illustrious Vogue models are just some of the "Images of Women" that make appearances in Valerie Alpert's work of the same name, which premiered on Alpert's company this past weekend at the Joyce Soho. The piece explores women's difficult relationship with consumer culture and the mass media and how that relationship affects the more intimate and personal one between themselves and their own bodies.

The work delves into the terrain of anorexia and bulimia, lipo-suction, plastic surgery, women's sense of self in the face of near perfect -- our cultural standard of perfect, of course -- and images and ideals of women. From the bevy of television and magazine advertisements that open the piece, to the more light-hearted act of choosing an outfit, "Images of Women" presents the myriad of emotions women can go through when dealing with the vicissitudes involving their bodies. It attempts to reveal the lengths women will go to attain the ideals perpetuated by the larger culture, how that striving can affect them, and their relationship to the world and each other.

"Images of Women" opens with just that: a splicing together of television and magazine advertisements and other recognizable scenes and faces from the mass media and entertainment industry. And, here, Alpert has done a nice job of immersing her audience in the seemingly endless standards of beauty a woman can be confronted with. They range from late-nineteenth century corset advertisements to the more modern-day commercials for Botox injections. The piece moves into a sort of affirmation in the section that follows. Entitled "I AmĚ," it reveals dancers entering clad in simple white leotards. The space is suddenly stripped of the clutter and cacophony of mass culture and the dance begins.

Three cylinders are equidistantly placed across the stage. Dancers pose on these pedestals as if for a fashion shoot, but this is a more introspective moment in the work, one of affirmation and inner strength. At least that is what Alpert seems to be trying to express here. The dancing is strong and almost animalistic, the tone of the section in stark contrast to the video that preceded it.

As the piece continues, Alpert explores more issues -- the hunger and loneliness of eating disorders, the bonds of female friendship, the coming to terms with one's self, both internally and externally, and continually tries to reaffirm women's sense of internal strength. The work ends with the phrases "Empower Yourself" and "Accept Yourself" fading in and out of the video screen. It's a little too precious of a conclusion and could have just as easily been omitted as the work and choreography literally screams this message across in and of itself. Sometimes less is really more.

Other sections are more playful. For instance, one scene spoofs GAP and J-Crew underwear advertisement in which women in pastel bikini tops and briefs arrange themselves into playful, sensuous, seductive, and kittenish poses. In yet another section, a woman is struggling to pick out an outfit for the day. She flails around and gets into and out of clothes, and is nearly strangled to death by a pair of uncooperative jeans. While she changes from one outfit to the other, she glances in the mirror, which is rigged to reflect the thoughts in her head. Her rear becomes that of an elephant, her face grows wide, her stomach expands, and she grows old. This is both funny, pathetic, and tinged with sadness. (It helps that the fact that the young dancer in this piece actually fits into all the clothes.) The work concludes with childish games of leap frog, patty cake, and ring around the rosy. There is skipping and joyfulness and I'm not sure what Alpert has meant to end with here. It's as if the women, in baby pink, blue and yellow capri pants and tank tops, are free and safe and carefree during childhood and only then.

What is most obviously missing in this work is any indication of what is known as the "male gaze," that overarching, patriarchal force or vantage point from which women have been scrutinized and judged for centuries. What we seem left with, then, is a feeling that the beauty culture of America is somehow solely a women's world -- created by women, imposed by them, and something meant for women only to suffer with. There is no nod to who set the standards, or the fact that men themselves are now dealing with the results of the ubiquitous six-pack toting, male model. Unfortunately, "Images of Women" hits upon too many cliches. It is territory that has been well-mined in recent years, and one is left with the feeling that the work is sort of superficial, lacking in what is just below the surface, what is beyond the din of the consumer culture. For instance, what are the real reasons that individual women (not just women as a whole) are effected by body image issues?

Alpert does try to take a stab at challenging the larger cultural ideals of what a woman should be and look like, but perhaps it would have been more interesting and challenging if she had pushed her message a step further by presenting dancers of varying body types instead of dancers whose body types are relatively the same as those one is likely to see in advertisements. What is difficult with this proposition, of course, is that maintaining a certain physique is par for the course in dance. It is also no secret that dancers themselves are notorious for severe body image problems. If not in the whole piece, then why not in a section or two present the normal, everyday female body? The one who wakes up and goes to work, takes care of children, works out on the elliptical, walks a dog, eats what she wants, takes yoga, karate, body builds, or does countless other things that shape her body into something very different from a Kate Moss clone, a Victoria's Secret model, or one of Charlie's Angels. Then, and only then, will we have a real grasp of the true, real life images of women.

The cast of dancers, who gave fine, open and lively performances, included Kimberly Davis-Wallace, Brooke Franklin, Jennifer Torres, Pei-shan Tsai, Jenna Wilayato, Liz J. Zamora. Lighting design was by Andrew Meyers, Dan Prowse, Jr. was the sound designer, and video was by Ms. Alpert.

Go back to Flash Reviews
Go Home