back to Flash Reviews
Flash Report, 5-27:
Graham in Turmoil
Seasons Cancelled, Union Suing
By Paul Ben-Itzak
Copyright 2000 The Dance Insider
The ongoing tragedy afflicting
the Martha Graham company took another dramatic turn yesterday,
when the dancers' union announced it will file an unfair labor practice
complaint against the company with the National Labor Relations
Board after the Graham board announced it was suspending operations
and canceling upcoming performances.
"Any employer has to
bargain with its employees about the effects of going out of business,
and the company didn't do that," Alan Gordon, executive director
of the American Guild of Musical Artists, told The Dance Insider.
"The company doesn't have the right to just go out of business when
they're union... If they're not paying anybody and not doing performances,
legally it's going out of business. The company had an obligation
to bargain with us in advance. If they had, we might have been able
to act sooner."
Fortunately, Gordon said,
in its last contract negotiations the union got the company to agree
to post a security bond. "It looks like we have at least a week's
salary for everybody, and maybe more," he reported. The dancers
are in the 23rd week of a 25-week contract, he added.
"Everyone's sorry they
had this financial crisis, but it shouldn't be our dancers who bear
the burden of their fiscal mismanagement," he said.
Just who is responsible
for any alleged fiscal mismanagement was the subject of much finger-pointing
Friday. Acting board chairman Francis Mason blamed ousted artistic
director Ron Protas. "He is the cause behind the entire matter,"
Mason told The Dance Insider. "The deficit is an accumulated matter,
and he has been the artistic director and guiding light of the company."
Mason was not immediately ready to comment about the union action,
as he only heard of it when The Dance Insider asked about it.
Protas, who could not
be reached for comment by the DI, told Lewis Segal of the L.A. Times
yesterday that the board was to blame. "They haven't raised the
money to go on," said Protas, who now chairs the recently established
Graham Trust, which owns the ballets. The trust's attorney, also
speaking to the Times, said a just-concluded U.S. tour had wracked-up
a deficit of $300,000, leaving the company "a half million dollars
in the red."
There seems to be some
general agreement on that figure. Mason said the board voted Thursday
to suspend operations and cancel upcoming seasons at the American
Dance Festival in Durham, N.C. and at the Kennedy Center because
otherwise, it would have faced an accumulated deficit of $500,000.
(An October season in Los Angeles is also in jeopardy, according
to the Times.) "We owe people so much money, we can't go to Durham
and pay the dancers when we can't pay the people we owe money to,"
Charles Reinhart, co-director
with his wife Stephanie of ADF (of which Graham was a co-founder
some 70 years ago) and of dance programming at the Kennedy Center,
told Jennifer Dunning of the New York Times, "I'm going to try everything
possible to make the performances happen. We have no other choice."
He insisted, "You cannot cancel performances you contract for just
before they happen." The Graham company is slated to open the ADF's
season June 8, with a three-day program that includes the classics
"Satyric Festival Song," "Diversion of Angels," "Deep Song," "Lamentation,"
"Errand into the Maze," and "Appalachian Spring." With the Paul
Taylor company, it is scheduled to open the Kennedy Center dance
season in September. Neither Reinhart nor a Kennedy Center publicist
returned phone calls yesterday.
The betting among some
dance insiders is that in some form or another, the ADF season will
The irony is that a company
founded by one of the strongest women dance has ever seen now sees
its immediate fate largely dependent on the machinations of three
of the field's wiliest old male foxes: Protas, an amateur photographer
who Graham latched on to and to whom she eventually willed her ballets
after he faithfully attended her when she lay mortally ill in hospital
in 1968; Mason, longtime editor of Ballet Review, one-time literary
collaborator with George Balanchine, and strong-willed chairman
of the Graham board in the 1970s; and Reinhart, perhaps dance's
last true impresario.
None of these men are
The betting here is on
Reinhart, as ingenious as he is tireless, the ultimate paragon of
the saying, "The show must go on." Reinhart has pulled rabbits out
of his hat before, continuing with Stephanie to lead an organization
that thrives despite federal funding cutbacks. One dance insider
speculates that Reinhart might negotiate to acquire a post-Graham
troupe of ex-Graham dancers to perform her choreography at ADF.
But even if Reinhart
pulls that off, the company's long-term future appears to be extremely
problematic. This episode is just the latest fracas in a five-year
recent history of financial crises, cancelled seasons, AGMA complaints
and political contretemps. The company sold its building in 1998
to pay off a deficit of $2.4 million, and Protas agreed about the
same time to turn over the artistic reigns to former Graham dancer
Janet Eilber. He had a change of heart in March, and the board had
to force him out.
If the potential long-term
tragedy is the threat to the Graham legacy, the immediate one is
the threat to the livelihood of the dancers. Indeed, the irony is
that they have never been performing with more artistry or dedication.
And that even though it is on their shoulders and their artistry
that the legacy of Martha ultimately rests, they have very little
control over the actual fortunes of the company. While the dancers
are just about the only thing that has been reliable about this
company in recent years, they are always the first to suffer when
the administrators and funders around them can't get their acts
together. So the company finds itself in the bizarre position of
having the premiere choreographic canon in modern dance, authentic
and dedicated dancers ready to deliver, presenters eager to book
it and audiences ready to cheer it -- and nonetheless being not
ready to deliver.
Said senior Graham dancer
and associate artistic director Christine Dakin: "The dancers are
shocked and feel horrible, not just for themselves but for the audiences
that will miss this opportunity, and we'll try and be hopeful."
back to Flash Reviews